Shouting

SofaSoGood

Registered User
Nov 22, 2019
13
0
Hampshire
My father, in the “later stages” of Alzheimers apparently, is endlessly difficult and frankly destroying the lives of my mother (aged 84) and myself. His behaviour prevents us having any proper existence at all. Mum feels “he can’t help it” but I think - as do others who’ve known Dad for years - that there is an element of wilful “naughtiness”. All his life he enjoyed winding people up, being sarcastic and provoking others. In my view that part of his personality has remained intact
One friend said that he’s like a naughty little boy, mischievous and testing the boundaries. possibly that’s right. I don’t know
What I do know is that my mother, who isn’t left alone with him very much, ends up shouting at him regularly. Despite her “he can’t help it” rubric, which applies to me not her, she yells at him for being provocative and difficult
Once in a while I do the same thing because he simply WON’T co-operate or show the most basic decency to me. Yes, I know it’s “sons and fathers” but I am not a saint - I never said I was - and every few days I reach the end of my tether and let him know what I think (for once) emphatically. I shout at him
And I feel that it works. He does respond when someone is so obviously furious with him, and he’s better behaved for a while
Is it wrong to shout? Am I supposed to keep my temper, be calm and speak kindly whatever he does or says? I raise this as a genuine question. When I yell at him and tell him (some of) my true feelings I feel better & he does seem to respond positively, for a while
Is it so bad of me? Or could it be a form of therapy
It’s just so easy to blame oneself all the time in this situation. What’s the best thing to do and say from day to day or hour to hour?
Guilt eh? We live with it all the time
 

Banjomansmate

Registered User
Jan 13, 2019
5,466
0
Dorset
When I heard The Banjoman being rude to his Care Home staff I always told him off and told him to behave. He looked sheepish but stopped. They looked at me as if they didn’t believe what I had just done!
 

TNJJ

Registered User
May 7, 2019
2,967
0
cornwall
My father, in the “later stages” of Alzheimers apparently, is endlessly difficult and frankly destroying the lives of my mother (aged 84) and myself. His behaviour prevents us having any proper existence at all. Mum feels “he can’t help it” but I think - as do others who’ve known Dad for years - that there is an element of wilful “naughtiness”. All his life he enjoyed winding people up, being sarcastic and provoking others. In my view that part of his personality has remained intact
One friend said that he’s like a naughty little boy, mischievous and testing the boundaries. possibly that’s right. I don’t know
What I do know is that my mother, who isn’t left alone with him very much, ends up shouting at him regularly. Despite her “he can’t help it” rubric, which applies to me not her, she yells at him for being provocative and difficult
Once in a while I do the same thing because he simply WON’T co-operate or show the most basic decency to me. Yes, I know it’s “sons and fathers” but I am not a saint - I never said I was - and every few days I reach the end of my tether and let him know what I think (for once) emphatically. I shout at him
And I feel that it works. He does respond when someone is so obviously furious with him, and he’s better behaved for a while
Is it wrong to shout? Am I supposed to keep my temper, be calm and speak kindly whatever he does or says? I raise this as a genuine question. When I yell at him and tell him (some of) my true feelings I feel better & he does seem to respond positively, for a while
Is it so bad of me? Or could it be a form of therapy
It’s just so easy to blame oneself all the time in this situation. What’s the best thing to do and say from day to day or hour to hour?
Guilt eh? We live with it all the time
Hi.I don't live with dad (I couldn't do it because I think in all honesty I would be done for murder)But I know where you are coming from.I do get impatient though with him as he knows very well what he is doing.He is a very high functioning person with a lot of awareness.He knows he has memory problems etc.I have tried the compassionate communication with him but it doesn't work .He will take more of the Mickey with me(game playing).I tell him straight.I find that works better for us.
You might find it changes from hour to hour day by day.No body can remain calm 24/7.So you have to what you think is correct at the time.
My dad can be rude and forget his manners.He soon gets reminded by me.Just because he has dementia does not give him an excuse to be rude to me or anyone.It is different if people are further along their path but not so him..We definitely do live with guilt!
 

Hil76

Registered User
Jan 5, 2020
50
0

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
139,064
Messages
2,002,828
Members
90,840
Latest member
Trey0407