How to obtain a CRAG valuation by a surveyor knowledgeable with CRAG

Willing

Registered User
May 23, 2014
1
0
My LA has accepted the need for a CRAG valuation for my mother in law's beneficial share of the family home - needed to determine her 'notional 'capital in respect to her financial assessment for care home fees [ after discussions as to what was actual or notional capital]. She has been in a home since November 2012 and was previously fully funded. Her husband continued to live at their house which was held as tenants in common. After his death, the LA assumed her 50% was 50% of the deemed marketable value. This is not the correct position to take as her husband's share was left to his three sons. Without a 'willing buyer', her beneficial share could be deemed to be nil. Neither the LA or I know who to approach with regard to finding a surveyor suitably experienced and knowledgeable with regard to 'CRAG' valuations. We live in the South West.

In the same vein and as a warning to others, the LA initially sent forms to complete in case there was insufficient liquid funds to pay for her fees. I may be wrong, but it would seem, the LA would then charge 8% for this deferred payment agreement or they could put a charge on the property if we failed to sign. I understand that a charge cannot be put on a property held as tenants in common or where, as in this case, there are several owners [holding part of the property in trust until it was sold.) Neither would any interest be able to be accrued on any charge that was able to be put on a joint tenancy or singly owned property.

Any advice on the subject of CRAG valuations would be more than welcome.
 

nitram

Registered User
Apr 6, 2011
30,361
0
Bury
Contact http://www.rics.org/uk/ and find a Chartered Surveyor specialising in property valuation.
Ask for an 'open market valuation' of the share of the property taking into account that the co-owners are unwilling to sell.
 

WILLIAMR

Account Closed
Apr 12, 2014
1,078
0
http://www.alzheimers.org.uk/site/scripts/documents_info.php?documentID=112

Take a look at the above mentioned link.
As the co owners are unwilling to sell it looks as if the patients share in the property will be worthless.
Nobody will buy half a house when somebody else can live in it.

I know of a case where a council wanted the daughter to sell a 6 bedroom house worth about £800,000 because the council says it is far too large for one person to pay the father's care fees.

The daughter has just refused to sell and the council is having to pay.

William
 

nitram

Registered User
Apr 6, 2011
30,361
0
Bury
The problem could be that the financial assessment team are afraid of getting brought to task by their internal audit and would like an official document to exonerate themselves.

The cost of a valuation by a suitable RICS member could put the matter to rest.

The cost would be low in comparison to the financial and emotional savings, I would argue that it could be taken out of the Mother's finances.